Showing posts with label Harem. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harem. Show all posts

Saturday, June 27, 2026

17. HAREM

MARIA’S LOVERS (1984) marked one of the major career highpoints for Nastassja, which makes the disjointed and flawed follow up film, HAREM (1985), seem all the more disappointing. The very odd HAREM is not a total failure and has its pleasures but it would be the least valuable film Nastassja had made since SPRING SYMPHONY (1982) several years earlier.
HAREM was the brainchild of writer and director Arthur Joffe. The French born Joffe got his start in the early part of the eighties on a series of acclaimed short films before graduating into HAREM, his first feature length production. HAREM feels very much like the work of an inexperienced filmmaker as it never finds a consistent tone, and Joffe makes the mistake many young filmmakers make with their first production in that he attempts to tell the audience everything while convincing them of very little.
The opening shot of HAREM is a bit of a perfect encapsulation for everything that is wrong with the picture. Joffe begins his film with a visually impressive shot of the Statue of Liberty as it is being worked on by construction workers in the mid eighties. This overtly symbolic shot (the lady liberty in a cage…get it?) feels so overbearing and Joffe fills HAREM with needlessly heavy handed shots like this one. It is as though he isn’t totally convinced by his own material, and shots like this opening only point out the film’s failure to connect with its audience.
The main problem though at the heart of HAREM isn’t Joffe’s direction, which is at times very nicely done when he just allows the film to play, but is the script. Co-written with first time screen writer Tom Rayfiel, HAREM asks the audience to accept some of the most implausible situations imaginable. Unfortunately the script is so poorly conceived and rendered that there is never a moment where we fully accept what is happening to Kinski’s character or her reactions.
Nastassja plays a lonely New York stock broker named Diane, who is kidnapped on a boat to Liberty Island and ends up in another country in the harem of a sheik. While in this foreign land, Diane learns the ways of the harem and eventually falls in love with the sheik. That is, in essence, the plot of HAREM and it is as ridiculous as it sounds.
The opening shots of HAREM, outside of the Statue of Liberty shot, are actually quite good. Joffe does a very good job at showing us the kind of like Diane is living and why she might be unhappy with it. He also photographs New York exceedingly well and it should be mentioned that the cinematography by Italian photographer Pasqualino De Santis is lovely. Unfortunately the film begins to fall apart as soon as Kinski is kidnapped. Joffe’s script stops allowing her to behave like a real person at this point and even the most skilled of screenwriters would have trouble selling how accepting this independent young woman is to the conditions she is thrown into.
HAREM could have perhaps worked as a romantic fantasy had the role of the sheik been cast better, but unfortunately the usually reliable Ben Kingsley gives one of the blandest and most unconvincing portraits of his career and there isn’t a spark of chemistry between him and Kinski.
Kingsley was on a major role when he shot HAREM. He had won the Oscar just a couple of years previous for GHANDI (1982) and he was becoming one of the most respected actors in the world. There is no questioning how great of an actor Kingsley is but his performance in HAREM is nearly unbearably smug and stilted. Of course much of the blame lies in the script, but Kinsley’s attempt at being a tender misogynist comes across horribly wrong. There is never a moment when we can even begin to believe Diane would fall in love with him and their scenes together finally become laughable.
Kinski does the best she can with the material and she is extremely good in the early New York scenes (Joffe should have abandoned the HAREM idea and just made a film about this interesting character’s life in New York) but, like Kingsley, there is only so much that Nastassja can do with the material offered her. HAREM is finally one of her weaker performances but at the very least she is incredibly beautiful as photographed by Santis, it is just a shame that the script lets her down so badly.
HAREM does have its virtues. As previously mentioned it is an exceptionally photographed film and the score by Philippe Sarde is extraordinary. Joffe handles the quieter scenes in the film exceedingly well and some of the shots of the harem have a nice hallucinatory hazy feel about them. Still the film is ultimately disappointing and even with its virtues it is hard to recommend it.
HAREM would open up in Europe in the late fall of 1985. Amazingly it would do quite well upon its release and it was a multiple Cesar nominee. It isn’t hard to argue with the accolades presented to the Costume design and photography though as they are sublime. Joffe has been relatively unprolific since HAREM and it would take him five years to follow up his first feature film, with ALBERTO EXPRESS in 1990, and he has only completed two films since.
HAREM would get a delayed and short US release and appeared on video and laserdisc in the late eighties courtesy of Vestron. To my knowledge, and please correct me if I am wrong, HAREM has never been released anywhere on DVD. Used copies of the VHS are not hard to come by here as the film has never built any kind of substantial following in the States.
HAREM is said to be quite popular in France and I have heard it remains a staple on television over there. I have also heard that the Vestron video I am familiar with is edited but I have not been able to verify this. I would be most curious to see any extra footage but I doubt seriously that it would change my opinion of the film, one of the most disappointing of Nastassja’s golden period.

Critical Reactions: Harem

I have unfortunately not been able to find many critical reactions to HAREM. The following are just a few I found online. I will add more in the future as I find them.

"It is hard not to be impressed by the single-mindedness of Joffé who, with only a few shorts to his credit, garnered $10 million, Kinski and Kingsley, and made his own movie...What might have been an intriguing clash of cultures soon dissipates into a listless drama of will they/won't they, until the Tragic Irony of the finale falls completely flat. Fine credentials (attractive decor by Trauner, delicate photography by De Santis) but little inspiration."
-Time Out-

"This film's two well-known stars -- Nastassja Kinski as Diane, a sophisticated trainee on the New York Stock Exchange, and Ben Kingsley as Selim an Arab mogul -- are hard-put to bring life into this beautifully photographed but under scripted romantic drama...it is an interesting role reversal, Diane has no qualms about bedding down an attractive man, but Selim's harem is purely decorative -- he does not share her cavalier view of sexual relationships. The twist is that Selim is not really that bad -- in spite of the fact that he has kidnapped the girl, he actually feels compelled to uphold a time-honored tradition that he doesn't really believe. Selim is an aesthete who wants to embrace the ways of the Western world."
-Eleanor Mannikka, All Movie Guide-

"Some years after graduating from the French film academy IDHEC, Joffé made his big screen debut with a lavish but ill-conceived English language film called "Harem" (1985), in which a lonely Arab prince (Ben Kingsley) kidnaps a woman (Nastassja Kinski) off the streets of New York in order to introduce her to a different lifestyle, against her will. The movie wasn't very good, but over a million people went to see it."
-Lisa Nesselson, ArthurJoffe.com-

The clipping presented at the top is available at the official website for Arthur Joffe. Unfortunately there isn't a lot of information on HAREM there either.

Shooting Kinski #15 (Pasqualino De Santis)


While HAREM is arguably one of Nastassja's lesser films from her best period, it is at the very least a gorgeous looking production. This is in no small part due to the lovely photography of acclaimed cinematographer Pasqualino De Santis, an artist who worked with many of the great film directors in the world throughout his career.
De Santis was born in Italy in the spring of 1927. The future Oscar winner got his start in film as an assistant cameraman with one of his earliest jobs being among other things a Steno horror-comedy. After a decade of working in this capacity the obviously talented De Santis graduated to the role of cinematographer on the 1965 production THE MOMENT OF TRUTH, directed by famed Francesco Rosi.
After working with Rosi that first of many times, De Santis' career took off and he quickly became one of the most in demand DPs in Italy. His big international break came when he was hired on by Franco Zeffirelli for his legendary 1968 film of ROMEO AND JULIET. De Santis became known for his inventive lighting techniques and the breathtaking way he could shoot actors, specifically women.
De Santis won a well deserved Oscar for his work on Zeffirelli's production and within a couple of years after he had already worked with everyone from Vittorio De Sica to Federico Fellini. It was a grand time in Italian cinema history and De Santis was a key part of it.
The sixties closed with De Santis' stunning work on Visconti's THE DAMNED, another project that would acquire him a lot of justified acclaim. He would work with the great Visconti again on another amazing productions, such the masterful DEATH IN VENICE (1971) and the lovely THE INNOCENT (1976) where he got a chance to shoot Laura Antonelli.
The seventies were an amazing time for De Santis and he continued to work with some of the world's most important directors including Robert Bresson, Joseph Losey, and Ettore Scola. His work with Bresson was particularly mind blowing as he shot both LANCELOT OF THE LAKE (1974) and THE DEVIL PROBABLY (1977). The latter film would mark a change for De Santis as Bresson demanded a more earthy and gritty style of photography which in turn would influence much of De Santis' work afterwards.
De Santis' work in the eighties isn't as notable as the seventies but that has more to do with the quality of films being made rather than the photographer's talents. By 1984 he was stuck shooting John Guillermin's disappointing SHEENA with Tanya Roberts. The similar looking HAREM would follow it and while it is not among the best projects De Santis took on his camera clearly loves Nastassja and his photography always keeps the disappointing film interesting.
De Santis health began to fail in the late eighties and his work became less and less prolific. He passed away just after his 69th birthday in the summer of 1996. His final project was, fittingly enough, a film directed by Francesca Rosi entitled THE TRUCE (1997).
Pasqualino De Santis was a rare talent and his work made all of the productions he shot noteworthy. His finest work with some of the great European directors remains awe inspiring, and his photography of some of the most beautiful women in screen history (including Nastassja) is one of the reasons God saw fit to invent cinema. May he rest in peace...

Odds And Ends: Harem


HAREM would turn out to be Nastassja's weakest film since SPRING SYMPHONY and a real let down after the extraordinary run of films she had just filmed. Still, HAREM is well worth revisiting if just for the lovely photography and great score by Sarde (which apparently has not had a proper release).

I recently found these lobby cards listed on Ebay, but otherwise HAREM has proven a difficult film to find a lot of material on, Nastassja's follow up film is just the opposite though. I will begin my look at one of the most pivotal, if for all the wrong reasons, of all of Nastassja's films later this week. Expect a lot more postings than you have been seeing the past couple of weeks.

Harem Cards

Photobucket

Photobucket