Showing posts with label One From The Heart. Show all posts
Showing posts with label One From The Heart. Show all posts

Saturday, June 27, 2026

This One's From The Heart


Up next I will be looking at one of the strangest and most controversial films in Nastassja's filmography, Francis Ford Coppola's ONE FROM THE HEART. This 1982 feature has divided film fans and critics since it was first released and it is a difficult film to write about. I have very strong feelings on it though and hope I can do it some justice in the next week or so.
While not necessarily hurting Nastassja's career, the films disastrous initial reception would set in motion a series of films for her that typically would be greeted with more disdain than acclaim, even though almost all of her films from this period have taken on major cult status. Perhaps none more so than ONE FROM THE HEART.
My look at this wild, flawed and ultimately very brave film will begin in the next day or so. I am entering into Nastassja's greatest period and I extremely excited about it. I hope anyone who might be reading will share in it and enjoy the posts.

7. One From The Heart (1982)


There are very few films that can accurately be described as being unlike anything other. Francis Ford Coppola's challenging 1982 film ONE FROM THE HEART is one of those few films. The feature was one of the most notorious failures in screen history when it struggled to play in just a handful of theaters in 1982 but it has since undergone some critical and popular rethinking. ONE FROM THE HEART would all but destroy Francis Ford Coppola's desire to have his own group of players in his own self contained studio system, and it would finally bankrupt him financially but not artistically.
ONE FROM THE HEART is a tough film to write about. It is a flawed film that can't truly be considered among Coppola's greatest films but the work has to be admired for just how brave and uncompromising in its vision that it is. ONE FROM THE HEART is part old fashioned romantic comedy part old Hollywood musical but built, by 1982's standards, out of the most progressive shooting methods ever employed for a film. Coppola's shooting and editing style on this work (chronicled in the dvd's amazing supplemental section) was over a decade before its time and would influence countless filmmakers. The film remains a clear example of one that has to be seen, reading and writing about it can't really come close to describing its many charms and weaknesses. So the following should be looked upon as maybe some scattered notes rather than a full review of the film.
ONE FROM THE HEART'S plot is remarkably simple. A couple, Hank and Frannie, have a fight on their fifth anniversary and split up. On the night of their break up Frannie meets the suave waiter Ray, and Hank meets the mysterious Leila and the film follows the four of them as they recount their dreams, disappointments and desires. Hank and Frannie are played by Frederic Forrest and Teri Garr while Ray and Leila are played by Raul Julia and Nastassja Kinski.
After the gruelling four year long ordeal that had been APOCALYPSE NOW (1979), Francis Ford Coppola wanted very much to create a simple old fashioned love story that would be filmed entirely on stages at his Zoetrope studios. Nothing is ever simple with Francis Ford Coppola though and the production of ONE FROM THE HEART became its own particular apocalypse. Dogged by financial difficulties, a massive and overwhelming set and stage scheme, crew walkouts (although at one point the majority gallantly worked for free), leaked press reports damning the film before anyone had ever seen it and a director that was falling apart trying to keep it all together, it is a miracle that ONE FROM THE HEART managed to get completed at all.


The film's virtues are easy to point out. The sets are stunning, with special mention going to the brave work of Production designer Dean Tavoularis. The music by Tom Waits is lovely and haunting as is the cinematography by legendary Vittorio Storaro (with assistance from Ronald Victor Garcia). The acting is uniformly good with special mention going to the young Raul Julia and Nastassja. The lead work by Forrest and Garr is fine but both of them at times feel slightly miscast (something I will get to in a second). Finally the direction by Coppola is always solid and at times inspired...so what is wrong with ONE FROM THE HEART?
The main problem I see with the film is that stylistically it is so inventive and so progressive that it frankly overwhelms Coppola's extremely slight screenplay. Add on the decision to set the film in modern times, even though the studio scenery and full frame photography all suggest old Hollywood and you've got an oddly disjointed film. Garr and Forrest are excellent in the lead roles but Coppola has the characters so underwritten and normal that his astonishing set simply buries them. Kinski and Julia come out better because they are more exotic and are allowed to not simply fade into the background. Nastassja's Leila is one of her most haunting, if smaller, roles and her performance of LITTLE BOY BLUE is one of the unquestionable highlights of the film, as is her final monologue about the art of disappearing.


Most of ONE FROM THE HEART'S fault indeed does belong in Coppola's script which he wrote with Armyan Bernstein with additional dialogue by Luana Anders. Bernstein was an inexperienced screenwriter and it shows as ONE FROM THE HEART'S storyline and dialogue always feels a little hollow. Anders, who did such great work on films like SHAMPOO (1975) and PERSONAL BEST (1982), probably gave it some flair but I think the script of ONE FROM THE HEART needed an entire makeover to make it the equal of Coppola's magnificent creative achievement.

Problems aside, I like ONE FROM THE HEART. I admire it and always like revisiting it. There was always something touching about it and when one views the documentaries on the film it feels simply revolutionary. It is also apparent from the dvd extras that this film never stood a chance as the press seemed absolutely obsessed with destroying Coppola and his dream studio..
I wish ONE FROM THE HEART had been a success as I have always loved the idea Coppola had for Zoetrope. It was to be not only a place where he could shoot his own films without studio interference and with his own actors but also a place of learning. Talented young actress Rebecca De Mornay is one of the films many 'understudies' and one of the most stirring aspects of the documentary is the shot of children coming to visit the set to see how a film is made (including Coppola's own children Sofia and Roman, both of who would attend the premiere with him and would later become accomplished writers and directors in their own right). Coppola's films are often centered around family and his movie company would have been as well.
Had ONE FROM THE HEART succeeded there is no question that Nastassja's career would have turned out differently. Coppola had planned on making her one of his key Zoetrope players and the two got along well during the shooting of the film. The film's crushing failure made this impossible though and the two never worked together again, although on the film's great audio commentary Coppola says that he would like to.
ONE FROM THE HEART is among the key films of the eighties and it is a work that visually is pretty untouchable. Its faults and failures perhaps make its sweet and sentimental tale of a love that is vanishing all the more poignant. It is currently available in a two disc set from Fantoma, featuring a group of extra features that are among the best ever offered on the home video market.

Soundtrack #4. One From The Heart (Tom Waits)



Even though he scored a much deserved Oscar nomination for the film's music, Tom Waits ONE FROM THE HEART is often overlooked not just by his own fans but also film lovers in general.
ONE FROM THE HEART represents Waits at a real turning point in his career. It is the last album he recorded before his audacious SWORDFISHTROMBONES record in 1983, an album that would set the experimental tone for the rest of his career. HEART ATTACK AND VINE(1980) had proceeded ONE FROM THE HEART and it had already shown Waits getting away from his more piano based music of the seventies, so ONE FROM THE HEART closes a real important chapter in Waits career.


Waits' singer partner on ONE FROM THE HEART was a surprising choice. Crystal Gayle was a popular country singer in the seventies, known for her smooth voice and incredibly long hair. Waits had originally wanted the sassy Bette Midler for his partner as the two had already done a memorable duet on his fantastic FOREIGN AFFAIRS album in 1978. Midler wasn't available in time for Coppola's film so Waits chose the softer, but no less accomplished, Gayle to accompany him.


Waits' soundtrack for Coppola's film works incredibly well as not only a musical companion to the film but also as a solid lp on its own. ONE FROM THE HEART might not be in the same class as SMALL CHANGE (1976) or BLUE VALENTINE (1979) as my favorite early Waits record but songs like BROKEN BICYCLES, LITTLE BOY BLUE, and especially THIS ONES FROM THE HEART belong in any music lovers home. Equally fascinating are the tracks that bookend the album, the OPENING MONTAGE and the quite astonishing PRESENTS that wraps things up.
Produced by Bones Howe and featuring some of the most straight jazz oriented material of Waits career, ONE FROM THE HEART might be an ideal introduction to Waits for someone who isn't perhaps prepared for the manic intensity of SMALL CHANGE or the more abrasive sounding BONE MACHINE. ONE FROM THE HEART might well be described as the most easy listening album of Tom Waits career, but that doesn't make it any less valuable.
Tom Waits of course would soon become well known as an actor as well and he has a memorable cameo in ONE FROM THE HEART. His first role, for Sylvester Stallone's PARADISE ALLEY (1978), would show Waits as being as charismatic on the screen as his unmistakable voice was on vinyl. Coppola would cast him in several more films of his including RUMBLE FISH and THE OUTSIDERS (both 1983) and THE COTTON CLUB (1984). He would unfortunately never score another one of Coppola's films again though.
ONE FROM THE HEART is available in a beautifully remastered gatefold edition cd with bonus tracks. Unfortunately Nastassja's infectious take of LITTLE BOY BLUE remains unreleased and the film is the only way to hear it.
Waits would lose the Oscar for ONE FROM THE HEART but it remains one of his most important albums if just for the door it closed for him. He was getting ready to, along with his new bride Kathleen Brennan, make a series of bold recordings that would cement his status as one of the most important musical figures on the planet. ONE FROM THE HEART is well worth grabbing for soundtrack fans and popular music lovers in general.

Shooting Kinski #7: Vittorio Storaro


To paraphrase one of Nastassja's later film, talking about the work of Vittorio Storaro is a bit like dancing about architecture. Some things have to be seen to be believed and Vittorio's greatest works for directors like Bertolucci, Argento, and Coppola have some of the most amazing photography you will ever see in cinema.
Halfway through the shooting of ONE FROM THE HEART, with everyone's nerves near shot Nastassja and Vittorio blew up at each other in a moment of frustration that has been well documented in many interviews over the years. Nastassja would speak of the incident to a British journalist over a decade later while promoting ONE NIGHT STAND. She would say, "I saw the rushes and I looked terrible, the lighting was so dark and the camera was the wrong angle. I said, how can an audience believes this guy sees me and goes crazy for me? And Vittorio Storaro said, 'You! I thought you were an actress! You're like all the other stupid people who only care about how they look.' And because he is so great you're not supposed to say anything. But I told him, 'Wait a minute. This situation demands I look great. Excuse me.' He never forgave me."
Regardless of the problems the two had together, Storaro's photography in ONE FROM THE HEART is one of its most lasting assets and in the final product Nastassja does indeed look great. Coppola gave him an incredible difficult assignment and Storaro managed to deliver a film that looked like no other.
Storaro was born in Rome in 1940. His father was a projectionist and he began studying photography before he was even in his teens. In his early twenties he got some work as an assistant camera man including what would prove to be a life altering job on Bernardo Bertolucci's BEFORE THE REVOLUTION in 1964.
He began his work as a cinematographer right around the time of his work on BEFORE THE REVOLUTION and shot a handful of films before ending up photography Dario Argento's first feature, the legendary BIRD WITH CRYSTAL PlUMAGE(1969). The wondrous work he did on that and his friendship with Bertolucci led to THE CONFORMIST (1970), a masterpiece that would cement his position as one of the most striking photographers in the world.
He would continue to do astounding work with Bertolucci on the films, THE SPIDER'S STRATAGEM (1971), LAST TANGO IN PARIS (1972), 1900 (1976), LUNA (1979), THE LAST EMPEROR (1987), THE SHELTERING SKY (1990), and LITTLE BUDDHA (1993). Throughout his career he has also worked with a variety of directors and photographed some of the world's most beautiful women including Stefania Casini, Laura Antonelli, Charlotte Rampling, Florinda Bolkan, Michelle Pfeiffer, Isabelle Adjani, and currently Paz Vega in the upcoming DARE TO LOVE ME.
Francis Ford Coppola greatly admired Storaro's work with Bertolucci and hired him for his 1979 feature, the masterful but nightmarish to shoot, APOCALYPSE NOW. The film would be the first of several he would photograph for Francis and they included, along with ONE FROM THE HEART, TUCKER, THE MAN AND HIS DREAM (1988), and LIFE WITHOUT ZOE (1989) from NEW YORK STORIES. ONE FROM THE HEART and APOCALYPSE NOW remain two high points of originality and perseverance for the talented Storaro.
There are many pages dedicated to and interviews with Storaro online so here are a couple of links for those interested.

http://www.cameraguild.com/interviews/chat_storaro/storaro_interview.htm

http://www.storarovittorio.com/inglese/

It is a shame that Nastassja and him had their falling out on ONE FROM THE HEART as they have never worked together again. She is as magical looking as the film's much heralded set design and stages. Storaro's painting with "light AND motion' suited her and Coppola's film very well, I am willing to bet their falling out was due more to damaged nerves more than anything else.

Critical Reactions #5 (One From The Heart)


In the wake of Michael Cimino's majestic but disastrously received HEAVEN'S GATE (1980) a film like ONE FROM THE HEART didn't really stand a chance when it premiered in 1982. After HEAVEN'S GATE, critics and film fans quickly turned their backs on many of the seventies most important American directors. This caused a number of truly astonishing films such as Peter Bogdanovich's THEY ALL LAUGHED (1981), Martin Scorsese's THE KING OF COMEDY (1983), Coppola's own RUMBLE FISH (1983) among many others to be greeted with outright hostility upon their initial releases. None were more ridiculed, and indeed more buried, than ONE FROM THE HEART.
Here is a sampling of critical reactions from 1981 and 1982 that range from a few positive to some quite brutal.

"This movie isn't from the heart, or from the head either; it's from the lab....ONE FROM THE HEART is like a jewelled version of a film student's experimental pastiche...Nastassia Kinski seems intended to be the spirit of something-of Vegas perhaps, or of romance itself...her scenes are the least enjoyable because she has no personality, but they're not painful, because she is very diffident and very lovely-a sad young vamp, slightly worn...she smiles her big empty smile as if she were visiting from another planet."
-Pauline Kael, The New Yorker-

"It doesn't work...the dialogue is especially silly as well as tediously repetitious...I hope Coppola will soon tire of his new toy and return to making movies."
-Pat Anderson, Films In Review-

"It's so easy to love ONE FROM THE HEART...sure and dazzling...sumptuous, sensuous, stunning..."
-Sheila Benson, Los Angeles Times-

"It clearly reveals the schizoid dream of Coppola's Zoetrope studio...Coppola has lost himself."
-Richard Combs, Monthly Film Bulliten-

"Garr and Forrest are even worse news in Coppola's long awaited flop...unpardonably wastes Nastassja Kinski...Coppola has a lot of explaining to do."
-John Coleman, New Statesman-

"Coppola pushes his cabin to the edge of the cliff. Then he cuts all his ties with solid ground, looks into the depths, and smiles...I didn't hate ONE FROM THE HEART but I was disappointed...Kinski gives promise of Dietrich like glamour and erotic mystery..."
-David Denby, New York-

"Runs out of money at the finish...Kinski fills her supporting role handsomely."
-Archer Winsten, New Yor Post-

"Coppola's manufactured event...the misused exquisite Kinski...an ultimate tribute to narcissism...the real subject is technique...not a disaster. It's not a legitimate even in it's own right, either."
-Joseph Gelmis, Newsday-

"Coppola's riskiest role of the dice...a hymn to Hollywood tinsel...nothing is real...feels like a musical but isn't...a magnificent abstraction, one from the state of the art."
-David Ansen, Newsweek-

"It's all technique and effects...self conscious, patronizing...Kinski is a lovely creature but the other three have not a flicker of charisma...The heart is missing."
-Judith Crist, Saturday Review-

"It is just a movie...spectaular...a movie about moviemaking...Coppola has worked from the brain and the gut. It remains to be seen whether he can make one from the heart."
-Richard Corliss, Time-

"The screening had an apocalyptic atmosphere...the title line is the first and last flickering sign of intelligence....Kinski is all visual tinsel...Coppola has thrown out the baby and photographed the bathwater."
-Andrew Sarris, Village Voice-

"ONE FROM THE HEART is an interesting production but not a good movie...The most dismal thing about ONE FROM THE HEART is that it lacks those rhythms. It is a ballet of graceful and complex camera movements occupying magnificent sets, and somehow the characters get lost in the process. There was never a moment in this film when I cared about what was happening to the people in it...Kinski, as a circus tightrope walker, has a beauty much more mature than in TESS and a wonderful moment when she explains "to make a circus girl disappear, all you have to do is blink your eyes."
-Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun Times-

and so it went...The critics were for the most part much kinder when the film got a celebrated brief re-release several years ago just before the astonishing DVD set came out. One of the most telling lines from above is, "Coppola's long awaited flop." I'm not sure how ONE FROM THE HEART could have succeeded in 1982 with this kind of attitude. Even more eye opening than any of these excerpts might be is the footage of a press conferance between Coppola and the press on the ONE FROM THE HEART set, that is featured on the dvd. Combative, angry and you can literally see Francis realizing that his dream project didn't have a chance.

Coppola on One From The Heart


An invaluable book on Francis Ford Coppola is the University Press of Mississippi's great FRANCIS FORD COPPOLA INTERVIEWS. Coppola talks a lot about the making of ONE FROM THE HEART as well as his feelings on the final product and what it meant to him.
Below are a few small excerpts from the book that I thought were worth posting here.

From an interview with Scott Haller in 1981:
"I wanted to take a fable like story and treat it almost the way Disney would approach a story in his animated films. Treat it with very expressive sets and lighting and music that heighten the story. If we made the movie in Las Vegas, it would have been just another relationship movie set on a real location with people jumping in and out of cabs, talking about their love affairs. I wanted to do something people hadn't seen before."

"The city (Las Vegas) is a metaphor for the state of love itself. I want the film to be the emotions of these people, just like in APOCALYPSE NOW."

"If we (Zoetrope) ever had a lot of money. We could be a very dangerous company."

From an interview with Lillian Ross in 1982:
"There is and can be content in technology. New tunes that we've never heard before, because they're never been possible before."

"I think it's wise to separate the earning of money from the making of a movie, but I wanted to own the rights to my own movies-to be the one to decide what to do with what I make. At the same time I was trying to use new methods. Everyone seems to be encouraging you to be ordinary, to tell the same old story the same old way, package it this way, package it that way. Just get the money. All that doesn't interest me. I like to experiment-to push the techniques of moviemaking forward and simultaneously find the most economical methods of making a film."

"If I have my own studio, to keep the control and supervision to myself, it is taking a risk. Taking risks, like this one creates some excitement. You may not have been excited, but others were."

"If you don't bet, you don't have a chance to win. It's so silly in life not to pursue the highest possible thing you can imagine, even if you run the risk of losing it all, because if you don't pursue it you've lost it anyway. You can't be an artist and be safe."

Rare Scans #5 (Sight And Sound on One From The Heart)


Here is a fairly rare article from a vintage Sight and Sound magazine detailing the making of Coppola's ONE FROM THE HEART. This is more technical than anything else but it does provide some insight on what it was like to be on the set making this difficult film and I thought it might be of some interest. As usual I am sorry for the poor quality. Please click on each to enlarge.

One From The Heart Lobby Cards



The best Nastassja Kinski gallery on the net is located at the fine Japanese site Nastassja Kinski Jp. It is linked over to the right and it is highly recommended. They have eight high quality scans of ONE FROM THE HEART color Lobby Cards. Here are three smaller sized version of them for your enjoyment, all featuring Nastassja.

Rare Scans #6 (One From The Heart Era)



Here are a few random images that I don't see much anymore. These are basically alternate shots of some much more commonly seen images from ONE FROM THE HEART. I thought, even in their sometimes poor quality, that they were well worth posting.

Nastassja On ONE FROM THE HEART

Here are a few quotes from Nastassja herself on Coppola and his film taken from various interviews, mostly around the time of shooting but also some later.

"It's so much a fashion nowadays to be cool and natural on screen. I think the most important thing is to be fascinating."

"The Hollywood experience was more theatrical than TESS, especially in the beginning. There was lots of improvisations and I felt a little awkward...Francis likes to say that actors control the pace and the scene, not the cutting man. That was completely new to me."

"Francis is one of a kind. He's got a great big heart and he's very honest. He wants people to succeed. He's unafraid to take chances. He wants to build a whole fantasy world inside this world that isn't so good. So do I...I play a circus girl in this one and I get to walk on a tightrope. In the beginning, the character was almost a magic person, a fairy almost. Now she's becoming more real. Still, I play an idealized person. She gives the man his life back, feeds his fantasies. She's everything or nothing. She could build a house on the moon and live with him there if she wanted."

"I started real low. It isn't like walking a straight line. It is like life in the toughest sense of the word. Gravity pulls you down everywhere and you really have to find the ultimate center of yourself. And because of my impatience, I got so frustrated and kept falling all the time. The I found an image of something pulling me up, something positive from outside and within, and it worked and it was like magic to me. I loved the circus people. Actually I thought of leaving everything and going to the circus. Those people put their life on a tiny string all the time. They know what might happen, but they're together and confront it all the time."

"ONE FROM THE HEART was fun to do, but I was so nervous. Coppola is another figure who is devoted to his family. Back then I knew his films of course, but I was greatly impressed by the man he was, is. When you went to his house, he was always with his wife and kids; it was never just him. To be there was a dream. Then we worked and did the film, and I was no less happy, but to be with the family was so special. To take one look at a family like that and, no matter what happens, you know that nothing could ever break them apart."

Rare Scans #7 (People 1982)

Odds and Ends #7 (One From The Heart)


ONE FROM THE HEART has gone from being one of Nastassja's most infamous films to simply one of her most famous. Fantoma's incredible dvd set went a long way in restoring this film to its proper status as one of the most important, if flawed, of the eighties.
A lot of promotional material exists for this film and its re-release from a few years ago. Many different poster designs have been used, some I have utilised here in these posts. I have also attempted to show a small sampling of the many lobby cards and promotional stills that exist for the film.Ebay and online sites like Movie Goods are always a good place to start in looking for this kind of material.
Very desirable are a handful of magazines with the most prominent being an issue of American Cinematographer that is almost entirely dedicated to the shooting of ONE FROM THE HEART. I am supplying a scan of its cover.

Nastassja was a major international star at this point and her image was appearing on dozens upon dozens of covers at this point, including some highly collectible Vogue magazines as well as the one pictured above.
ONE FROM THE HEART remains a very valuable film even though it is far from perfect. If it is at times a failure then it is at least a noble one, and I would much rather watch a noble failure than a great film made for strictly commercial reasons. Coppola's film is a tribute to artistic perseverance, integrity and finally family. Nastassja was a part of that family for a while and who knows perhaps one day she will be again.

Screenshot of the Day: One From The Heart

Nastassja on eBay: Some Rare Promotional Designs

A rare film card from the mid eighties featuring several different images of Nastassja:
Photobucket

A terrific PAL VHS of One From The Heart sold on the strength of one of Nastassja's most iconic photos:
Photobucket

A large foreign Magdalene design quite different from the typical one sheets:
Photobucket

A large Italian version of the On A Moonlit Night one sheet (an upgrade to the VHS version I offered here before with the same image):
Photobucket

A Yugoslavian version of the Maria's Lovers poster:
Photobucket

A rare image advertising Maria's Lovers:
Photobucket

A lobby card I haven't posted before for The Hotel New Hampshire:
Photobucket

Finally, a rare look at the cover of a promotional booklet for the very limited US release of The Moon In The Gutter:
Photobucket

Kinski and Coppola on the set of One From the Heart


Nastassja Kinski: Two Promo Slides and a Chinese Playing Card



Nastassja Kinski: One From the Heart Promo Slide and Japanese Pin-Up


Kinski: One from the Heart Lobby Cards and Slide