Showing posts with label Spring Symphony. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Spring Symphony. Show all posts

Saturday, June 27, 2026

9. Spring Symphony (1983)


SPRING SYMPHONY (1983) is a real odd film in the early career of Nastassja Kinski. It differs from nearly all of the other films she made at the time in that that it isn't controversial, nor unfortunately is it very interesting.
The film very much does seem to be a personal project for Nastassja as she had some involvement in getting it produced but it suffers at nearly every turn with flat direction, a dull supporting cast and poor pacing. SPRING SYMPHONY's biggest flaw though is just how much it under uses Nastassja, who is essentially featured in just a supporting role and the work goes for long, dreadfully dull, stretches without her appearing.
SPRING SYMPHONY was advertised as a look between Robert Schumann and his mistress Clara but the reality is that the film mostly centers on Schumann alone, who is portrayed a dull lifeless bore by German actor and rock musician Herbert Gronemeyer. Gronemeyer's filmography is very small and he is probably best known cinematically for his work on DAS BOOT (1981). The relatively inexperienced actor (who is also credited with the film's score) is asked to carry this film and he simply doesn't have the charisma or acting chops to do it.
Director Peter Schamoni worked consistently throughout his career on a number of documentaries and shorts to some acclaim, but his work here is as lifeless as his leading man. The film suffers majorly from his extremely erratic pacing and his poor script that often just relys on musical performances to pad out its running time.
Cinematographer Gerard Vandenberg had worked mostly in television and it shows here as the film's look is rather flat but thankfully the production design by Alfred Hirschmeier is well done as is some of the costume work.
Nastassja, who barely appears in the first half hour, is okay in her small role. As the part is woefully underwritten there was no chance of it being one of her more accomplished performances. Her piano recital scenes are strong though and it is obvious that she put a lot of work into making the playing look as authentic as possible. She looks lovely at the very least and her very presence gives the film more kick than it has any right to.
It is easy to see what would have attracted Nastassja to the film, as she is a huge music fan and it is a fascinating story. Unfortunately the screenplay by Schamoni feels like a group of disconnected scenes thrown together without much thought and it is regrettable as this film really could have been something special.
SPRING SYMPHONY remarkably one two awards when it was released including one for Nastassja at the German Film Awards and incredibly one for Schamoni at the Bavarian film awards.
This West German production played for a brief time in Europe in 1983 but wouldn't get a Stateside release until 1986. It remains one of the lesser films of the first half of Nastassja's career and is recommended only for hardcore fans. It is available in a bare bones dvd release, which at the very least offers the superior German track as an alternative to the old VHS's English dub.

Rare Scans #11 (The Time Cover Story


Here is the cover of Time magazine that Nastassja appeared on in 1983 as SPRING SYMPHONY was opening in Europe. Richard Corliss wrote the article and it contains a pretty in depth interview with Nastassja. As usual I apologize for the poor quality of the text as it is a copy of a copy.

Critical Reactions #7 (Spring Symphony)

Here are a few vintage reactions to what I think is one of Nastassja's lesser films.

"What makes SPRING SYMPHONY a special experience is the gusto that director Peter Schamoni brings to the tale. The performances, camera work, and music score positively bubble with the heady German romanticism that Schumann and his epoch were steeped in...Kinski combines strength and sweetness, giving both qualities a touch of iron."
-David Sterritt, Christian Science Monitor-

"The film impresses you musically and dramatically but it's done with a nervous, skittering rapidity...Kinski may be a matter of taste, this reviewer has a schoolboy crush on the gorgeous actress and is grateful for any chance to watch her."
-Michael Wilmington, Los Angeles Times-

"A promising opening...gives way to a mishmash of short scenes in which neither Schumann's creative genius nor his relationship with Clara is much illuminated."
-Nick Roddick, Monthly Film Bulletin-

"enjoyable...careful, fragmented, convincing...Kinski is too old to play the teenage Clara with such doe-eyed innocence."
-Rex Reed, New York Post-

"Kinski continues to mature as an actress, and as she matures, she dazzles. She seems to be a person of many depths and currents, and all of these come to bear on the role of the young woman who must choose between father and lover. It's a brilliant performance."
-Mike McGrady, Newsday-

"as education, it's awe inspiring...Kinski does some impressive hand synching on the keys, but is so curiously subdued when she's supposed to be petulant that we long for some of the annoying mannerisms she had before she added the 'J' to her name...trifling, irritating, boring."
-Michael Musto, Village Voice-

"a remarkable attempt...Kinski is astonishingly convincing and moving...her best work since TESS."
-Howard Kissell, Women's Wear Daily-

"Schamoni's film is impeccably cast, with Hoppe as Wieck, his damp eyes suggesting incest here as chillingly as they did evil in his portrayal of Goering in Mephisto; Grünemeyer pale and intense as the boy-genius; and Kinski irritatingly placid as Clara. And the director captures perfectly the spirit of a Germany founded equally upon the tenets of stuffy burghers and high-minded student drinking associations, while cinematically echoing the Romantic style of Schumann's music."
Time Out Film Guide-

"It's a German film, and the Germans also have a word for it--kitsch. Frisky Nastassja Kinski is the pianist Clara Wieck; glum Herbert Gronemeyer (of Das Boot) is the composer Robert Schumann. They stare deeply into each other's eyes, bounce through flowery landscapes, and urge each other on to ever greater heights of artistic achievement. If only they'd urged writer-director Peter Schamoni to greater heights."
-Dave Kehr, Chicago Reader-

I was surprised to see some of the more positive reactions this film garnered but I am always happy to see Nastassja's work being acclaimed. SPRING SYMPHONY will always be a lesser Kinski film in my eyes but as you can see from above, the work did manage to captivate several critics upon release.

Odds and Ends #9 (Spring Symphony)


Despite some acclaim, I think SPRING SYMPHONY is one of the least notable films from the golden period of Nastassja's career. At the end of the day it is a relatively small role in a minor film.
The usual amount of promotional material is available on the film although apparently not a lot. The usually reliable moviegoods.com doesn't even have a poster for it and Nastassja KInski Jp only has a screen shot from the dvd. Occasionally some items pop up on ebay but overall material from this film is hard to find.
Nastassja hasn't spoken much about the film throughout the years, and I couldn't find too many more things to say about it so I am going on as her next film as it is one of her most interesting.

Spring Symphony Japanese Pamphlet at Kinski JP


My friend at Nastassja Kinski JP, the definitive Nastassja Kinski site online has posted some terrific scans of the rare Spring Symphony Japanese Press booklet. It can be viewed at this link. Thanks to him for continuing to run such a beautiful and essential site...and for his support here.