Friday, July 6, 2007

5. Cosi Come Sei (Stay As You Are) 1978

After making two films back to back that were beneath her quality wise, 1978's COSI COME SEI (STAY AS YOU ARE) would turn out to be a refreshing change of pace for Nastassja Kinski as well as the first film she made that garnered substantial worldwide attention.
Directed with flair by veteran Italian director Alberto Lattuada, STAY AS YOU ARE tells the tale of a fifty year old man who is having an affair with a teenage girl who turns out to maybe be his daughter. The film is most notable for the pairing of legendary Marcello Mastroianni with the young Kinski. The role, for Kinski, would suddenly prove her not only as a great star but also as one of the most commanding young actresses of the seventies.
Scripted by Lattauda and Enrico Oldoini, from a story by BLACK BELLY OF THE TARANTULA director Paolo Cavara, STAY AS YOU ARE could have played as a totally smarmy and tasteless film but instead it holds up remarkably well as a poetic, if slightly twisted, look at a man having a major mid life crisis and the young woman who captures his heart.
Oldoini and Cavara had just come off the interesting Corrine Clery thriller, PLOT OF FEAR, when they came up with the idea for STAY AS YOU ARE. Lattauda was the perfect choice as director as he had just finished filming the pairing of middle aged Max Von Sydow and young Eleonora Giorgi in DOG'S HEART.
Produced by Bernardo Bertulcci's cousin, Giovanni, with Ennio Morricone providing a heartbreaking and incredible score along with the remarkable cinematography of Almodovar favorite, Jose Luis Alcaine, STAY AS YOU ARE had an incredible unit behind as well as in front of the camera.

This lovely to look at film has a certain disappointed and dreamlike quality that runs throughout its near two hour running time. Mastroianni really excels in the role as an unhappily married man who falls head over heels for the vivacious Kinski. It is one of his best, if most underrated, roles of the seventies and he plays it beautifully throughout. Perhaps the most interesting thing about Mastroianni's performance is how well he conveys the sense of losing control. He knows he is doing the wrong thing but he finds himself unable to stop himself, nobody was better than this great Italian leading man at showing this kind of internal strife. It is interesting to note that Mastroianni had just come off Ferreri's brilliantly crazed BYE BYE MONKEY where he would act at times as the voice of reason in the film to young Gerard Depardieu, while in STAY AS YOU ARE he is literally playing a man who has lost all reason and is seeking a voice for it.
As wonderful as Mastroianni is in the role, the film belongs to 17 year old Nastassja. Stunningly beautiful and authoritative, her work in STAY AS YOU ARE is still an eye opening experience. Even critics who didn't care for the film went out of their way to praise the young Kinski, who in the role of Francesca has to convey a sense of someone who is becoming more and more in control not only of their own life but also Mastroianni's Giulio. Kinski is at times soft and tender in her characterization but she never for a moment lets us forget that ultimately Giulio's destiny will finally be of her own choosing.
The pairing of Mastroianni and Kinski was inspired. The two have a real kinetic and joyous chemistry together and their love scenes, as well as just the way Marcello's kind but weary eyes stare lovingly at Nastassja, are still a wonder to behold. It must have been a thrill for Nastassja to work with one of her favorite actors at such a young age. She has often made mention throughout her career at how much she admired Fellini so the prospect of working with one of his greatest leading men must have been overwhelmingly exciting to her.
STAY AS YOU ARE does break down a bit towards the end. It plays out a little too long and the film's final moments are a little too simple for the films good. I get the feeling that ultimately Lattauda didn't know how to end the film and finally just perhaps took the easiest way out.
STAY AS YOU ARE also has a great supporting cast to go along with its fabulous leads. The fine Spanish actor Francisco Rabal provides great support as does Spanish actress Monica Randall in what could have been a thankless role as Marcello's wife. Also keep a look out for future Argento and Fulci star Ania Pieroni making her feature debut in a small but solid role.
Morricone's score is remarkable and I will be looking at it in more detail in a future post. STAY AS YOU ARE would unfortunately be the next to last feature film for Lattuada who would mostly work in Italian television before his death two years ago. The talented, and prolific, Alcaine would begin his legendary collaboration with Almodovar ten years after the release of STAY AS YOU ARE and he remains one of the great cinematographers in modern cinema, with the amazing VOLVER among his most recent works.
STAY AS YOU ARE still has the capability to really jolt modern audiences with it's very R-rated subject matter, full frontal nudity and the possible incestuous relationship that is at its core. It isn't a film that could made in the present climate of modern cinema which is probably this reason that it remains out of print and unavailable on dvd in America. It's politically incorrect nature shouldn't turn modern viewers off, at its heart the film is more about watching two great actors playing off each other much more so than its improbable plot.
Nastassja Kinski's fourth film, featuring the most important of her pre-TESS roles, remains one of her hardest to find. Briefly available on VHS in the eighties before slipping out of print, STAY AS YOU ARE now fetches very high prices on Ebay and Amazon. It has been released on dvd in Europe but unfortunately that dvd does not feature English subtitles or the, admittedly awful, English dub track. With most of Kinski's most important work available on dvd in America, the absence of the lovely and controversial STAY AS YOU ARE is very disappointing.


Rogue Spy 007 said...

I had never heard of this film, but it sounds amazing. I love movies that push the limits of what is acceptable and comfortable in our society. This movie would definitely not get made in today's PC climate. Those on the left and right who abhor this sort of thing would be out in full force to get it snuffed out before it even got made. What man, whether he's 16 or 76, wouldn't fall for the beautiful creature that is Nastassja. I could imagine that any man's life could be spinning out of control, but would have found it hard to resist and turn away from her. I've always been a fan of Marcello Mastroianni. He's of the finest actors that have graced the screen. If Ennio Morricone had anything to do with the music, then I know it will be stirring. Great blog post about this movie. It's a shame that so many of the movies I would love to see are not on DVD.

Jeremy Richey said...

Thanks Keith for your thoughts...I will be posting some thoughts on Ennnio's amazing score in the next day or so...thanks again for commenting.

Anonymous said...

Stay As You Are is available out of Japan as a region 2 dvd. No English subtitles, but wide screen, unlike the dubbed VHS tape from Warner Bros. As it is, Nastassja's voice seemed to have been synched by someone other then herself. Not too surprising because Alberto Lattauda, a Fellini contemporary, shot film with no sound track and added the voices later.

There were region 0's, that were up on e-bay for at least 6 months and were exactly the same dvd as the region 2. The same could be said of Exposed on dvd that is widescreen.

noriaki78 said...

Hi Jeremy, I uploaded 2 digest movies Nastassja appears on Cosi come sei.

Part 1
Part 2

They are the original Italian version, but I think they are dubbed. However, Japanese DVD has an exellent video quality, you should get it if you don't have yet.

The Diligent Slacker said...

I was searching for this movie for a really long time, and i just found it online. I don't have the english dubbing with's in Italian. Do you have any idea, where i might be able to find the english subtitles? Kinski was amazing in Cat god, is she gorgeous?!

Nico B said...

STAY AS YOU ARE in Italian language with English subtitles and optional English dub is available on Blu-ray & DVD. Release date May 12, 2015

Nico B said...

Available on DVD and BLU RAY May 12, 2015. Order now on